Posted by: bluepinegrove | October 28, 2011

Pink Noise

I learned yesterday that there’s a name for the sounds I hear inside the hyperbaric chamber: pink noise. Two hours of this, without movies, would drive me bonkers. Here’s a minute of it.

Another kind of pink noise has been blaring this month. I think I may have the pink ribbon blues. I may blot some of it out with some reading. Here are a couple of additions to my reading list.

Bright-Sided: How Positive Thinking Is Undermining AmericaPink Ribbon Blues: How Breast Cancer Culture Undermines Women's Health

 

Barbara Ehrenreich was on NPR recently, talking about her cancer and about her aversion to forced positivity. All that pink-ribbon-and-teddy-bear stuff annoys her, and I for one am glad someone has so thoughtfully articulated this annoyance.  Though I have friends and family members affected by breast cancer, I’m too cynical to purchase pink-beribboned products. There has been an awful lot of corruption around this marketing ploy. However, like Ehrenreich, I have appreciated how pink ribbon-ers have contributed to raising the level of cancer awareness in our culture. I am very grateful that I don’t need to hide my cancer, that I can blog about it.

I know from participating in AIDS walks many years ago how powerful it feels to add to a large public demonstration of catastrophic private experiences. And I know how it feels to march with thousands to protest a war, even if it doesn’t have any immediate effect. Sometimes all one can do is stand up and yell, “Occupy THIS!”

Ehrenreich rejects the term “cancer survivor.” For her, the term is freighted with connotations of fighting and victory, and it implies that those who succumb to the disease are weak losers. Her interview made me feel guilty and a bit like a silly stereotype for using the warrior metaphor early during my cancer treatment. When I look back, though, I acknowledge that warrior-ship was a useful phase. It was the only way to handle the terror, and an effective way to focus. Despair was not practical. The battlefield, for me, was molecular.

And in my case, I didn’t feel that The System had anything to do with my cancer. I don’t feel it was caused by environmental corruption, but by a virus (and possibly a genetic marker). I had proper medical care, nobody did anything wrong when managing my precancerous condition. My cancer was treatable, and I chose to go for cure because it was an option. For that option, I’m very grateful.

Like Ehrenreich, I’ve been uncomfortable using the term “cancer survivor,” partially because I feel bad for those who didn’t have access to effective treatment, those who were killed by treatment, and those who were killed by cancer. And I don’t like the term because it implies that my relationship with cancer has ended. It hasn’t ended, and it never will. Every time my body does something peculiar, I’m back at the OhMyGodIt’sBack baseline.

My kind of cancer doesn’t have its own color of ribbon. If it did, would I wear it? Would it convey the full extent of damage wreaked upon me by cancer? Not possible. Would I wear it if I thought it would help someone else? Absolutely.

Advertisement

Responses

  1. A warrior is strong, empowered, unassailable. Warriors don’t have to kill anything because nothing can hurt them. One can take great comfort from that warrior part of the self. One becomes a warrior when one walks with that inner strength.

    • “Warrior” is a good, strong word, but I do wonder if some other archetype is more apt. Not feeling the warrior thing these days.

      Unless, of course, I’m so tough I don’t even have to think about it!

  2. Hi, blue pine grove! I heard that interview as well. I always appreciate her analysis – her book Blood Rites: the History and Origins of the Passions of War, especially, but I don’t think you should feel any guilt for having a different viewpoint.

    I’d say you’ve earned the right to pick any color ribbon you like.

    Wishing you books and movies that are up to the pink noise, nozknoz

    • NozKnoz, thanks for taking the time to read my blog. I really appreciate it.

  3. Hey Marika,
    Sounds like your holding up and that your spirit seems to be strong. That’s a good thing. I feel like you, in the respect that I wonder if I’m really cured. You mention the ribbon, and if you’d wear it, or support it if it helped others. I sometimes wonder about that too. Sometimes I feel proud to wear it. Like I have come out of something scary, and life threatening, and have something to be happy about. In fact, most of the time I do feel like that. Sometimes I feel a little guilty about all the pink ribbon hoop-la. Ya know? There is a LOT of pink ribbon stuff out there. It makes me think of all the money being funneled into the “popular” cancer. What about the other cancers that could use some research moneys? Don’t get me wrong, I’m extremely happy to be where I am, health wise.
    I wish you didn’t have to go through this stuff. But you know, I’m also thankful all these amazing treatments are available, my grandmother died of uterine cancer in 1940. Imagine what it was like for her. My mom was 15, and said it ate her alive. I think all she had was morphine. They’ve come a long way baby. So we can be grateful for that huh?
    Take care. I’ll check in again soon. Keep quilting, they’re beautiful.
    Love, Mel


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.